In this article
Online advertising companies can sell access to an audience, manage campaigns you own, produce the ads you run, or charge for the leads they deliver. A quote from each kind of supplier can look similar until you check who controls the media, which invoices you can reconcile, and what you keep at the end. Compare the business models before comparing prices.
What Different Online Advertising Companies Sell
Ask each of the online advertising companies on your shortlist who does the work and where the ads run. Use the following models when digital advertising companies offer similar-sounding packages. Some suppliers combine several models in one proposal, so ask them to identify each service they’re selling.
| Vendor model | What you’re buying | What to clarify |
|---|---|---|
| Ad platform | Access to the platform’s advertising inventory | Who manages campaigns and builds the ads? |
| Agency | People to plan, run, and report on campaigns | Which accounts will be used and which services are included? |
| Network or reseller | Access to media arranged through an intermediary | Can you see placements, spend, and any markup? |
| Creative studio | Concepts and production for ads | Who buys media and who owns the source files? |
| Lead provider | Leads or appointments that meet agreed terms | How are leads sourced, shared, and validated? |
Use the last column in the first call. It often tells you whether you are discussing one supplier or several suppliers working together.
Ask Why Each Platform Fits Your Buyers
A proposal should explain the job each of its online ad platforms will do. Google Search can reach people looking for a defined offer. A LinkedIn campaign can use professional attributes such as role or industry. A TikTok campaign may need native short-form video that shows the product or problem quickly. Ask the vendor what evidence supports each channel in your case and which assets you’ll need. Google Ads campaign types · LinkedIn Ads targeting · TikTok’s video advertising guide.
For example, a supplier of commercial refrigeration may prioritize searches for installation quotes while testing LinkedIn messaging for facility managers. Ask how you would judge those channels against their different jobs.
Put Media, Services, and Production on Separate Lines
For an advertising vendor comparison, give each bidder the same hypothetical monthly budget and show how the money is expected to flow. Ask for a quote broken into delivered media, fees, production, tools, and setup costs. A media buying agency might charge a flat fee, a share of spending, or a combination. Ask how the fee changes if you move money between platforms or reduce the total budget.
For example, a $12,000 package with $8,500 of media leaves $3,500 for the rest of the work. A quote for $10,000 of media and $1,500 of management starts at $11,500. Put both quotes on the same media budget before adding creative and tracking to the total.
See Where Spending and Campaign Records Live
Ask to see a sample invoice and report. Verify how the supplier matches what you pay with what ran, how it documents adjustments or credits, and what placement detail it can provide. If it operates through a package with limited platform-level access, document the evidence it can share and the decision that evidence will let you make.
Where campaigns run in your own accounts, list the business owners and agency users and note who can approve changes. Google Ads lets you set and update access levels. If the supplier also manages creative, check whether you get editable files as well as exports and which usage terms apply. Google Ads access management.
Read the Lead Delivery Terms Against Your Sales Process
If a supplier charges by the lead, define what your sales team can act on. A commercial cleaning company might require a business email, serviceable address, building size, and an indication of contract timing. Ask whether the same inquiry goes to other buyers and what the prospect agreed to when submitting their information.
Agree how to identify duplicates, reject out-of-area leads, and request credits with evidence. Calculate the eventual cost per qualified opportunity. For example, 30 leads at $40 each cost $1,200. If six meet your criteria, that’s $200 per qualified opportunity before counting the sales team’s time. Use that figure to compare with any campaigns your business runs directly.
Decide Who Keeps the Advertising Assets Fresh
A media proposal can cover budgets across several platforms while leaving production to you. Ask who will write briefs, create new concepts, and adapt finished work to the placements you intend to buy. Review a real asset request and see whether your team can deliver the approved files and claims on the proposed schedule.
Consider the website or form in the same discussion. If you’re selling a higher-priced product with installation, the page needs to explain service coverage and help buyers request a quote. Agree who can update it as campaign results come in. Zita’s guide to campaign-ready websites covers that side of the scope.
Start With a Pilot You Could Hand Over
Give finalists the same offer, market, media budget, and business goal. Ask for a short pilot scope with delivery dates, the assets or permissions they need, the source of the numbers they will report, and what happens if the campaign needs to pause. Use that scope to compare the first billing cycle and the steps required to end it.
The best model for your brief depends on which capability you want to add. An in-house buyer can hire a studio for more ad concepts. A lean team may need an agency that can run the pilot and help determine the value of each channel. Confirm what you will be able to keep running if the work moves back in-house.
Bring the vendor quotes you’re weighing and your first campaign goal. Review your advertising scope with Zita Marketing.

